Being pregnant has turned me into a hoarder.
Please don’t call A&E on me.
I have developed an intense desire to buy everything in bulk so it lasts until “after the baby comes.” As if, on the day our child enters the world, all stores will cease to exist. They will simply disappear in the oblivion ushered in by the birth of our offspring (perhaps eaten by the Langoliers? No, DEFINITELY eaten by the Langoliers).
I am now the proud owner of 96 rolls of toilet paper AND 96 rolls of paper towels, delivered last week. No, I didn’t mean to buy the same number of each. It’s my calculating pregnancy brain at work. In other news, I think our UPS guy hates me.
But, at least we’ll be able to lead semi-civilized lives after the apocalypse rears its ugly head, no?
Plus, I made ice cream! This fabulous ice cream is made without a machine and is filled to the brim with Reese’s deliciousness! One bite and you won’t care about the apocalypse. Promise.
(Not an actual promise…I mean, it’s the apocalypse. You’re totally going to care, even if there is amazing ice cream)
- 2 cups heavy cream
- 14 ounces sweetened condensed milk
- ⅔ cup creamy peanut butter
- 1 cup of Reese’s Mini Peanut Butter Cups
- ⅔ cup Reese’s Pieces
- Beat 2 cups of heavy cream until stiff peaks form. Set aside.
- Microwave the creamy peanut butter for 5-10 seconds, or until runny. In a large bowl, combine the 14 ounces of sweetened condensed milk and peanut butter until well-combined. Fold in the whipped heavy cream until no white streaks remain. Gently stir in the Reese’s mini peanut butter cups and the Reese’s pieces.
- Place in covered container and freeze overnight (or at least 6 hours).
Check out these other frozen treats from other awesome bloggers!
- Cookie Dough Ice Cream Cake by The Domestic Rebel
- Easy Peanut Butter Cheesecake Ice Cream by Crazy for Crust
- Cantaloupe Popsicles by Damn Delicious
- Peanut Butter Lover’s Ice Cream by Dinners Dishes & Desserts
- Peeps Bubblegum Ice Cream by Pint Sized Baker
{ 42 comments… read them below or add one }
This looks so easy…I have never made ice cream without my machine. If there is an apocalypse anytime soon, I am hoping it doesn’t involve any of Stephen King’s creations! And if there isn’t one, well, you are well stocked, that’s for sure! I feel like a crazy hoarder when I buy 2 of the giant 24 pack! Tell the UPS guy at least it isn’t 5# bags of flour!
Haha – very true! The boxes were big, but not particularly heavy
First of all, I think have 96 rowels of paper towel and toilet paper is a great idea. If I had storage I would buy in big bulk like that. So a big “you go girl” to that!
And on to this ice cream, oh my goodness, yes yes yes yes yes yes yes!
Thanks so much, Pamela! I think my “nesting” started a little early
Peanut Butter heaven – love the cups and pieces!!
Thanks, Erin!
I am freezing my ice cream container now!!!
No ice cream machine needed, Cathy!
I made a PB Reese’s ice cream treat this week too! It’s posting Friday, I can’t wait for you to see it! Great minds think alike.
Haha! This just happened with me and Mike from Semi Sweet, with our Breaking Bad cupcakes
In our case, I bet its a pregnancy thing! 
I can’t wait to see your recipe!
Yay! I love ice cream made without a machine…especially when it has peanut butter!
Thanks, Mimi!
Yay for desserts with Reese’s Pieces! I don’t blame you for stocking up on things. I do that all the time. We have soap delivered by the case every month.
That reminds me…I should probably stock up on soap too
Wow I am so glad I found your blog! I mean sharknado cookies – soooo awesome. AND an easy ice cream like this loaded with chocolate and peanut butter? Stop it. I’m hooked.
xo Jackie
Aww, thank you, Jackie! I’m so glad you like what you see so far
I hope you like what I’ve got up my sleeve!
Uhhhh-mazing!!! Love the loaded cups! My husband would love this. PS: Tell your UPS guy you are keeping them in business.
Haha, very true, Zainab!
Since I have moved to the country, I also have become a hoarder! I can’t help it. The store is so far away that I have this need to shop til I drop every time I go to town.
And as far as the UPS man goes, make him some cookies or this fabulous ice cream and he will like you again. I promise.
Oh that reminds me, I need to pick up some dry ice for this in case of the apocalypse!
Growing up, we always lived pretty far from a “real” grocery store – about 30-40 minutes away! Luckily though, there was a tiny, locally-owned convenience store that we could go to in a pinch
And, for the record, the UPS guy has always been very nice and professional, I just feel bad for making him lug all of those boxes to the house!
LOOOOVE peanut butter and chocolate in my ice cream! My absolute favorite flavor combo…any which way. Reese’s Pieces, Reese’s PB Cups, swirls of PB, crushed Nutter Butters and chocolate chips, etc. Terrific recipe, Jennifer, and thanks for sharing! P.S. Don’t worry. Your maternal instincts are kicking in to “be prepared” for your little one.
Thanks so much, Stacy! The nesting has definitely started to kick in
I get where you’re coming from! You just wanna have everything ready for when baby arrives lol. And obv. you need paper products and lots of candy!
AND THIS ICE CREAM!
Oh yes, I’ll stockpile ice cream too!
Oh my gosh, this could be my new favorite ice cream! It’s so full of peanut butter and chocolate goodness!
It is super yummy – my husband gobbled it up!
So much goodness in one bowl! I had no idea you could order toilet paper and have it delivered. I’ve been doing it wrong all this time!
Amazon is the best!
Hi Jennifer,
This looks insanely good!
Thank you, Asmita!
This ice cream was made for me- love the peanut butter overload!
Thank you, Meghan!
I’m happy that you don’t need an ice cream machine to make this. I hope I don’t make 96 batches though!
Haha – that might be a little too much
You know how to hit my weak spot! PB cup ice cream – how heavenly! I love the no churn ice cream – it sure makes things easy. I love the way you think! I hate shopping for that kind of stuff. One less thing for you to worry about.
Thanks, Reeni! I figure the less random chores I have to worry about after our little one gets here, the better
Needs no machine??? Peanut Butter Ice Cream??? I’m in!!!!
It is SO easy and yummy!
When the baby comes, you will absolutely not want to run out for toilet paper, so good planning! Now, you just need to make 96 pints of this for the freezer for when the baby comes.
Haha – yes indeed! We’ll needs lots of ice cream
Wow!!! Definitely, a frozen treat to die for… I am drooling!!!!!
Thanks so much, Denise!
{ 1 trackback }